Here at Simple Life, we spend a lot of time in Door County, so we'd like to think we know the best spots for a good meal. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a local looking for a new experience, here's a few of our favorite restaurants throughout Door County.

1. LA Sirena 

Ephraim, Door County

This new upscale spot comes from the Michelin starred owners of Taco María in California, and features elevated yet comforting cuisine. They're known for "one special dish at a time," meaning a prix fixe meal with limited availability and modification options for vegetarians. During the winter, a smaller, two-course menu is offered, with a full four-course menu during the warmer months. Be sure to check out their site for the current offerings.

2. Kitty O'Reillys

Sturgeon Bay, Door County

Kitty O'Reillys is a relaxed, welcoming spot in Sturgeon Bay that feels like home the moment you walk in. It's the kind of place that works just as well for a casual dinner as it does for lingering over a drink after a long day out in Door County. With comforting food and a friendly atmosphere, it's a favorite for both locals and visitors looking for something familiar and enjoyable.

3. Donny's Glidden Lodge

Jacksonport, Door County

Donny’s at the Glidden Lodge offers a classic Door County supper club experience with a focus on well-prepared, familiar dishes. The menu centers on fresh fish, steaks, and other comforting favorites that pair naturally with the relaxed pace of dining here. Located right on the water in Sturgeon Bay, it’s a great spot to settle in for dinner and take in views of Green Bay after a full day of exploring the peninsula.

4. chives

Baileys Harbor, Door County

This welcoming yet refined spot in Baileys Harbor is known for its thoughtfully prepared, seasonally driven menu that highlights local ingredients and creative flavor combinations. Chives offers a relaxed fine-dining experience where each dish is crafted with care and intention, often reflecting what’s freshest from the region. The menu changes regularly to showcase the best of each season, and while reservations are recommended, the intimate setting makes every meal feel personal. Be sure to check their website for the current dinner offerings and seasonal specialties.

5. Barringer's Restaurant

Fish Creek, Door County

Barringer’s is a longtime Fish Creek favorite known for its refined take on classic American cuisine. The menu features thoughtfully prepared dishes like steaks, seafood, and seasonal specials that balance comfort with a slightly elevated touch. With its cozy, intimate dining room and consistently well-executed food, Barringer’s is a reliable choice for a relaxed dinner that still feels a bit special during your Door County stay.

One of the best ways to experience Door County is through its food. From relaxed supper clubs to thoughtfully prepared, chef-driven meals, these restaurants offer a glimpse into the local flavors and slower pace that make the peninsula so special. Whether you’re planning a special night out or simply looking for a great place to unwind after a day of exploring, each of these spots adds something memorable to a Door County stay. 

When you stay with us at The Simple Life Rentals, you’re never far from a great meal or a comfortable place to come back to at the end of the day. We hope to see you soon!