Blue Skies and Cherry Pies

Wonderful

Elizabeth M. - Posted: 10/13/2025

Hello Karla, Thank you for your kind words! We’re delighted to know you had a wonderful stay and would love to welcome you back anytime. Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Wonderful house in a great location - near Fish Bay but in a quiet, wooded area. The house was well-stocked and clean. The open layout in the kitchen/dining:'/living room provided a nice view of the woods. We enjoyed the gas fireplace on cool nights. Overall, a very good visit & we hope to return next year.

Debra - Posted: 10/7/2025

Hello Debra, Thank you so much for sharing such kind words! We’re delighted to hear you enjoyed the peaceful setting and that the home had everything you needed for a comfortable stay. It’s wonderful that the fireplace made your evenings cozy. We’d be so happy to welcome you back next year for another relaxing getaway! Warm regards, The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

This propery was great for our family. The large kitchen and family room area made for a lot of space for us to hang out and play games. The propery was fun for our dog who got to roam off leash due to the large property and fairly remote from the busy streets and neighbors. The central location in fish creek made visiting neighboring towns easy. Also the bed was super comfortable. Propery grounds really well maintained and was neat to have a yard in the middle of the woods. Friendly neighbors. We had a great stay.

megan - Posted: 8/9/2025

We’re so happy your family (and your pup!) enjoyed the space, kitchen, and yard! Thank you for sharing your experience, we’d love to host you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We had a perfect girls family trip here. Had no complaints. Was very comfortable for the six of us. Beautiful home and yard. Loved sitting on porch in the morning coffee clutching with the family and making memories. Nice location. Wouldn’t hesitate to book again. Pricey but comparable to other places for high season in Door County.

Jennifer - Posted: 7/28/2025

Hello Jennifer,
Thank you for your review! We’re so glad your girls’ trip was comfortable and memorable, and that you enjoyed the home, yard, and morning porch moments together. We’d be thrilled to host you again!
Warm regards,
The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

This rental was as described and more. There are more amenities and conveniences than were listed in the description. They really thought of everything. There were extras of everything as far as linens. I did not need to bring my own tissues and tp. There are benches in the back hallway entrance and in the bathroom that made things so convenient. It was a perfect location for my family and my reactive dog. The quiet, private setting meant that my dog only had an occasional squirrel to complain about. She even got used to the delightful bird clock, and Flossie the metal goat sculpture. Lol. It is a short drive to Fish Creek shops, restaurants, and the marina. My mom enjoyed the local literature/information and we played some of the games. I would definitely rent from Simple Life again.

Christa - Posted: 6/27/2025

Wow, thank you so much for the awesome review! 😊 We absolutely loved hearing about your stay (and Flossie is always happy to make new friends, even the four-legged ones! 🐐😂). It sounds like you made the most of every little detail, and we’re so glad the home was a great fit for your family. We’d be so excited to welcome you back anytime!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Loved our stay. It is very centrally located in Door county, close enough yet away from the hustle and bustle.
Defintely coming back.

Prakarsh - Posted: 5/26/2025

Thank you for the kind words! We're so glad you enjoyed your time with us and found the location to be the perfect balance — close to everything, but still peaceful. We'd truly love to have you back whenever your travels bring you to Door County again.
Warm regards,
The Simple Life Rentals Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

Blue Skies lives like our own home. Immaculate bathrooms and a big beautiful kitchen. Even opted to eat in more than usual to take advantage of the great space. It’s spacious with nice amenities. Location and scenery perfect. Will book again!

Kerri - Posted: 10/21/2024

Thank you for your kind review! We are so glad you enjoyed your time and hope we have the pleasure of hosting you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

The house was lovely! We loved the privacy of the yard and the cleanliness of the home.

Nina - Posted: 8/22/2024

Thank you for your review, Nina! We are so happy you enjoyed your stay and hope you will consider joining us again.

Simple Life Rentals staff

We had a great time at this house, perfect location, the house was very nice and clean! The area was so nice and quiet and woodsy! We had plenty of room and always a bonus when we can bring our dog!!

Judi - Posted: 8/18/2024

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We're delighted to hear that you and your family, including your furry friend, had a fantastic time at our property. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future.

Simple Life Rentals staff

Near Fish Creek and Egg Harbor and others. Great art studio just down the street and great hands on crafts nearby. House was awesome and as described.

Marie - Posted: 8/8/2024

We appreciate your review, Marie! We are so grateful you loved the home as well as its location in beautiful Door County! Thank you for allowing us the pleasure of hosting you.

Simple Life Rentals staff

A perfect place tucked away in the woods but Fish Creek is easily accessible. Will come again!

Scott - Posted: 7/3/2024

Thank you, Scott! It was our pleasure hosting you, glad you had a wonderful stay!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Property location and house amenities made our vacation a fun time memorable event.

Stella - Posted: 7/1/2024

Thank you, Stella!! It was our pleasure hosting you.

Simple Life Rentals staff

We loved everything about this house and it suited our needs perfectly. We're have 3 generations of family staying and we love cooking at home. This was the perfect house to get to where we wanted to go and then come back to a comfortable and cozy house to make dinner and get the kids to bed. The house was super clean when we arrived and it had all the amenities listed that we expected. The grill was an awesome plus for our burger night. The 2 main bedrooms (queen and king beds) are great for adults and the bunk bed room which is super small was perfect for a 6 and 7 y/o who spend zero time in their room on a vacation anyway. The location is perfectly centered in the middle of everywhere and the longest car trip we had was up to the north part of the peninsula where you pick up the ferry to Washington Island. Otherwise, max 25 minutes to everywhere. We loved everything about our time at this house and will gladly consider it again if we come back to Door County. Thank you for a wonderful stay!!

Michael - Posted: 6/30/2024

Thank you, Michael, for providing such a kind and wonderful review to us and the community! We are grateful for you and hope to host your next visit! Gratefully, The Simple Life Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

We had a wonderful stay at Blue Skies and Cherry Pies in Fish Creek, WI. The home was exactly as described in the listing and surpassed our expectations. The location was nice and private, and very close to the town of Fish Creek. This made it extremely easy to get around Door County and be able to get back to home base easily. The house was immaculate; every room was very clean and it was very comfortable.
Communicating with Simple Life rentals was, well, very simple! We would definitely want to work with simple life rentals again and consider staying at Blue Skies and Cherry Pies in the future. Thank you for making our long weekend easy to enjoy!

Joe - Posted: 6/23/2024

We appreciate your kind feedback so much! We are thrilled to hear the home exceeded your expectations and worked great. We loved hosting you, Joe, and hope to host you again soon!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We really enjoyed our stay! Location was excellent. It was quiet and peaceful but close enough to downtown fish creek. Would definitely stay again!

Stephanie - Posted: 6/9/2024

Yay, Stephanie! You made our day and we hope to have the opportunity to host you again sometime.

Simple Life Rentals staff

A house in the woods. Quiet, clean, bright, spacious, comfortable. Everything in working order. A clean freak ways loves having a washer and dryer. A short ride to anywhere. Located at the end of the road is was delightful to have an area to allow my geriatric best friend meander far away from the roads. Everything was greatly appreciated. Just the three of us.

Phillip - Posted: 6/3/2024

Thank you, Phillip! Come back and stay soon, we loved having you!

Simple Life Rentals staff

The place was excellent get away. We enjoyed it, everything that we need was there. We decided not do any cooking, because we were on vacation and spend the time eating out. The dog enjoyed her stay and only slept on the bed with us for a few hours because of the thunderstorm that passed through. Meet the neighbor and he was enjoyable to speech with. The whole experience was excellent, will be planning on using this out fit again. Thank you

charles - Posted: 5/26/2024

Thank you, thank you!! These genuine reviews and your happy experience in one of our homes is why we do what we do. We hope to host you again soon, Charles!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Wonderful stay with my parents and husband! Very clean bright and cheerful. Great kitchen plenty of storage and lots of room for our family. Beautiful big outdoor wooded setting lots of windows and close to Fish Creek. Would definitely stay here again!

Heather - Posted: 5/19/2024

Thank you, Heather!! Come back and stay soon, we loved having you!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Property was lovely . Very peaceful . The house was spacious and had everything we needed . The fireplace makes it so comfortable on a fall day The location was close to town, shopping and restaurants .

Paulette R., Wisconsin - Posted: 10/28/2023

So happy to hear you had a great stay! Thanks for the kind feedback on the home, Paulette! It was our pleasure hosting you.

Simple Life Rentals staff

This home is set in the middle of a hardwood forest, which made for beautiful fall colors! It was so quiet and relaxing! The interior of the house is tastefully decorated and comfortable. The location is perfect for visiting all the nearby towns and Peninsula Park. We definitely recommend this place.

Margaret C., Stevens Point, Wisconsin USA - Posted: 10/5/2023

Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback. This means a lot to our team and owners to hear, glad you had a great stay!

Simple Life Rentals staff

This place is a gem. All four of us were so comfortable and pleased. So clean, and the kitchen was magnificent!
Close to so many fun things to do in Door County.

Maureen - Posted: 8/31/2023

Thank you, Maureen! We are so happy to hear this and greatly appreciate your feedback to us. Hope we may host you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We are first time visitors to Door County! They was several brochures on the desk and we scoped them out. All of the furniture made us feel at home! We had a few issues at first but the owner communicated with us quickly. Only one was not resolved. We looked for the TV remote in the bedroom and never found it. We do like watching TV in bed when we woke up but we just changed our plans for the stay. They didn't know where the remote may be!

Jeff - Posted: 8/26/2023

Thank you for all your feedback, Jeff! It was our pleasure to host you and we are glad you enjoyed your stay overall. Thank you!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Beautiful peaceful in the woods retreat. Definitely would stay again😊

Shari - Posted: 8/18/2023

Thanks so much, Shari! We look forward to hosting you again sometime!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Very nice location and great house!! Extremely clean. Very comfortable.

Sarah - Posted: 8/11/2023

Thank you, Sarah! This means so much to our team and owners. We are so happy you had a great stay and hope to host you again sometime!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Clean, comfortable house in the woods. Manages to feel simultaneously private and close to town at the same time.

Kate - Posted: 8/11/2023

Thank you, Kate!!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We absolutely loved our stay at Blue Skies & Cherry Pies! The house was spotless, which is very important to me. It had plenty of room for our family, and it was also extremely comfortable. The location was very peaceful and quiet yet close to everything in Fish Creek and just a great location overall. We loved sitting on the porch in the quiet mornings. We would absolutely stay here again!

Ronna - Posted: 8/1/2023

Thank you for taking the time to leave us your feedback, Ronna! We appreciate your kind review so much. Hope we can host you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We enjoyed our week here. The house was very clean and spacious. It had everything we needed & more. It’s secluded, yet close enough to everything. We would definitely stay again!

Kelly - Posted: 7/27/2023

Thank you for your kind feedback! It would be our pleasure to host you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Second year in a row. The ladies had a splendid stay! Already looking forward to next year!!

Jeff - Posted: 7/18/2023

We are so happy to hear this! We look forward to another opportunity to host everyone!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Really nice house, big and clean and well decorated and lots of amenities. Nice quiet location but still close to things. Definitely recommend.

Scott - Posted: 7/6/2023

Thank you, Scott! This means so much to us!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We enjoyed our weeklong stay in the woods outside of Fish Creek. This location worked well for our touring of Door County. The house was perfect for the 2 couples. Spacious bedrooms and bathrooms; large, well-equipped kitchen and comfortable living room. Very quiet area to relax. Enjoyed watching the squirrels defeat the "anti-squirrel" attachments to the bird feeders. :-) Our friends enjoyed bird-watching from the deck.

Kenneth - Posted: 6/20/2023

Hi Ken, so pleased to hear you enjoyed your time at the property and had a great stay! Thank you for sharing your kind feedback with us!

Simple Life Rentals staff

This house was the perfect getaway for us. It was clean, spacious, and had everything you could want in amenities. It's also close to all the various Door County attractions. Just a wonderful place....

Douglas C. - Posted: 1/4/2023

Thanks, Douglas! So pleased to hear you had a wonderful stay. Thank you for sharing your feedback. We hope to have an opportunity to host you again sometime!

Simple Life Rentals staff

We enjoyed our stay at this home! It was comfortable and peaceful, we wish we could have stayed longer. Would come back again!

Linda Y. - Posted: 10/16/2022

Thank you, Linda! We would be pleased to host you again!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Great

Robert - Posted: 9/24/2022

Thank you, Robert!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Beautiful home and property; very quiet. Everything you need for a relaxing time...just bring the groceries. Home and property are well maintained. The caretaker, and neighbor, greeted us upon arrival; a nice Wisconsin touch.

Michael A. - Posted: 9/9/2022

Thank you for the kind feedback, Micahel! We are so happy you enjoyed your time here and we hope we can host you in the future!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Wonderful place! It has a peaceful, in the woods, location but is still very close to local attractions. The communication from the host was fantastic as well.

Megan - Posted: 8/21/2022

We're glad to hear that you enjoyed your stay! Looking forward to hosting you here again.

Simple Life Rentals staff

A beautiful home for five lifelong friends to gather and relax. The house is spotless and so well appointed.
I will recommend to anyone who is looking for a wonderful retreat from the day-to-day grind!
Thanks so much!

Mary - Posted: 8/14/2022

We are so glad you and your friends had a wonderful stay!! We would love to host you again, thanks!

Simple Life Rentals staff

Exactly as described. Clean, in a secluded area, and close driving distance from town. Would recommend staying here.

Lisa - Posted: 8/7/2022

Hi Lisa,

We're glad and happy to hear that you enjoy your stay together with your family. Looking forward to hosting you here again.

Thank you,
The Simple Life Team

Simple Life Rentals staff

We loved the out-of-town, woodsy and peaceful atmosphere, yet not far from Main St. There was plenty of room, a well-equipped kitchen and great having 3 bathrooms. However we would’ve preferred at least another full size bed rather than 2 twin size bed in the second bedroom. It was also very clean and we would be willing to rent again in the future. Thank you! P.S. Beth was very helpful when we were locked out our first night.

Catherine R. - Posted: 7/13/2022

Thank you for sharing this feedback and for the 5* rating. Please come back and stay with us again soon.

Simple Life Rentals staff

We had a great time staying at this home in Fish Creek. It is a great location and it is a very beautiful house. It is very well cared for and very comfortable. It is close to so many things to do in Door County.

Terry B. - Posted: 7/11/2022

We are so glad to hear that you enjoyed your stay at Blue Skies and Cherry Pies. Thank you for the review and the 5* rating.

Simple Life Rentals staff

Large space with a great Kitchen area. Beds are The Bomb! I haven't slept so well in months.

Randy C. - Posted: 7/7/2022

We are so glad to hear that you got a good night's sleep! Thanks for the positive commentary and for the 5* rating on Blue Skies & Cherry Pies.

Simple Life Rentals staff

Loved the house and location. Only thing I would have changed is to have some furniture in the deck to enjoy. Otherwise perfect!

Sharon H. - Posted: 5/30/2022

Thanks for sharing this feedback and please come and stay with us again.

Simple Life Rentals staff